Free guides · plain English · written by Yash Chandpara

Made to order · Free insured delivery Australia-wide over A$500

IGI & GRA certified · Lifetime warranty

Education›Lab Grown Diamond Guidance›Are Lab Grown Diamonds as Good as Real Diamonds?

Lab Grown Diamond GuidanceFenora Guide8 min read

Are lab grown diamonds as good as real diamonds?

Yes — on every measurable quality dimension. The same hardness, the same optical properties, the same IGI grading, the same durability. Lab grown diamonds differ from mined only in origin and price. This guide gives the complete, honest assessment.

The question behind the question

"As good as real" contains an assumption worth examining: the assumption that mined diamonds are the reference standard of "real" and lab grown are measured against them. A more accurate framing is that both are diamonds — the same material — and the comparison is about which origin better serves a specific buyer's priorities.

With that reframing: lab grown diamonds are as good as mined diamonds on every quality measure. They are the same material. The IGI measures them identically. They have the same hardness, the same optical properties and the same permanence. The differences are in origin, price and resale value — not in quality.

“As good as? The question assumes mined is the benchmark. A better question is: are they the same material? Yes. Are they graded by the same standards? Yes. Are the quality grades directly comparable? Yes.”
— Yash Chandpara, Founder

The direct comparison

Dimension	Lab Grown	Mined	Verdict
Chemical composition	Pure carbon — cubic crystal	Pure carbon — cubic crystal	Same
Mohs hardness	10	10	Same
Brilliance	Same refractive index	Same refractive index	Same
Fire	Same dispersion	Same dispersion	Same
IGI grading	Same scale and criteria	Same scale and criteria	Same
Durability	Permanent — does not age	Permanent — does not age	Same
Daily wear	Excellent	Excellent	Same
Price	60–80% less	Carries scarcity premium	Lab grown better value
Environmental footprint	Significantly lower	Mining footprint	Lab grown better
Resale value	Lower	Higher (but still poor ROI)	Mined better for resale

Where lab grown exceeds mined

Better on these dimensions

Price per quality grade — identical quality costs 60–80% less. The budget goes further
Environmental footprint — laboratory grown, no land excavation, traceable origin
Consistency of supply — grown to specification. Specific qualities available reliably
Access to top grades — D colour, Flawless, Excellent cut is accessible in lab grown at prices that would buy far lower quality in mined

Where mined has an advantage

Better on these dimensions

Geological origin — if the fact that a stone formed underground over billions of years matters to the buyer, only mined provides this
Resale value — mined diamonds retain more resale value than lab grown. Neither is a good investment at retail prices, but mined is relatively better
Certain rare natural colours — natural fancy coloured diamonds (Argyle pink, natural blue) are different stones from lab grown coloured diamonds and are only available as mined

Common questions

Will my lab grown diamond look different to a mined diamond in a ring?

No visible difference in normal conditions. The same cut, colour and clarity grades produce visually identical results in a ring setting. A trained gemologist with spectrographic equipment can identify the origin in a laboratory — but in a ring on a hand, there is no visible difference.

Do jewellers treat lab grown and mined rings differently for repair or resizing?

No. The jeweller works with the gold or platinum setting and the diamond — the material is the same. Resizing, prong re-tipping and cleaning are performed identically.

Is a lab grown diamond a good engagement ring choice?

Yes — for buyers who value quality, value and ethical sourcing. The only situation where mined may be preferred is when the geological origin of the stone carries specific personal meaning.

Melbourne client care · Made in Surat

Lab grown vs mined quality questions? Ask Yash Chandpara.

Book a free online consultation. Yash Chandpara compares lab grown and mined diamonds side by side and answers every quality question directly.

Book Free Consultation Shop Engagement Rings

Are lab grown diamonds as good as real diamonds?

The question behind the question

The direct comparison

Where lab grown exceeds mined

Where mined has an advantage

Common questions

Lab grown vs mined quality questions? Ask Yash Chandpara.

Keep reading